If you are VAT registered in the UK, you are not stuck with one way of doing your VAT return. HMRC offers a handful of different accounting schemes, and picking the right one can make a real difference to your cash flow and how much admin you deal with each quarter. Most small businesses default to standard VAT accounting without ever checking whether the Flat Rate Scheme or Cash Accounting would suit them better.
The scheme you use affects two things: when you actually hand over VAT to HMRC, and how much work goes into each return. Get it right and VAT becomes a routine quarterly task. Get it wrong and you can end up paying VAT on invoices your customers have not settled yet, or filling in more detailed records than you actually need to.
This is the scheme most VAT registered businesses use by default. You record VAT on every sale and every purchase as it is invoiced, not when the money actually changes hands, then pay HMRC the difference between the VAT you have charged and the VAT you have paid. It gives you the most accurate picture of your VAT position and lets you reclaim VAT on purchases in full, which suits businesses with significant costs or those that regularly claim VAT refunds. The downside is that you can end up paying VAT to HMRC on invoices your customers have not paid you yet, which can strain cash flow if you have slow paying clients.
Under the Flat Rate Scheme, you charge VAT normally to your customers but pay HMRC a fixed percentage of your total turnover instead of the actual VAT difference. The percentage depends on your trade sector and ranges from around 4% to 14.5%. You keep the difference between what you charge and what you hand over, which can work out as a modest gain for some businesses, though this is less generous than it used to be since HMRC introduced a 16.5% rate for "limited cost" businesses with very low goods spend.
The scheme is only open to businesses with turnover under £150,000 excluding VAT, and once you join you generally cannot reclaim VAT on purchases except for larger capital items over £2,000. It suits service based businesses with few expenses, mainly because the paperwork is simpler.
Cash Accounting lets you account for VAT based on when money actually moves, not when you raise or receive an invoice. You pay VAT to HMRC only once your customer has paid you, and you can only reclaim VAT on purchases once you have paid your supplier. This is available to businesses with turnover under £1.35 million and can be a genuine cash flow lifeline if you have customers who pay late or on long terms, since you are never out of pocket for VAT on unpaid invoices. The trade off is that you also cannot reclaim VAT on a big purchase until you have paid for it in full, which matters less for most day to day trading.
You cannot combine the Flat Rate Scheme with Cash Accounting, though the Flat Rate Scheme has its own built in cash based method for working out turnover, which achieves something similar. You can move between schemes, but you need to notify HMRC and check the eligibility thresholds both when you join and as your turnover grows, since you must leave the Flat Rate Scheme once your turnover passes £230,000. Most accounting software, including Xero and QuickBooks, will handle the VAT calculations automatically once your scheme is set up correctly, but the initial setup and the decision itself are worth getting right the first time.
There is no single best answer here. The right move is to run the numbers on your actual trading pattern rather than picking whichever scheme sounds the most straightforward.
We review your numbers and recommend the VAT scheme that actually fits how your business gets paid, then handle the switch and the ongoing VAT returns.
Book a free consultation →